| WCFHL ORGANIZATORIAL RANKINGS By Eric Sherkin), March 8th 2004 |
These rankings take into account players on prospect lists ONLY. Players on pro contracts are considered graduated by this chart. Please take this into account before you bitch about where youre rated. 30. CHICAGO BLACKHAWKS Prognosis: This organization is a mess. With players like Eric Lindros, Al MacInnis and Adam Deadmarsh potentially on the verge of retirement, they desperately need some injection of youth. GM Mikko Vuoris love of drafting Finnish youth hasnt produced much help at the WCFHL level. Making matters worse, Chicago has only a 7th and 8th round pick in the next draft, and no 1st rounder the following year. 29. COLORADO AVALANCHE Prognosis: A perennial elite-level team, Colorados prospect depth is barren. They also have zero remaining 2004 draft choices. No impact players on the horizon, though Hedin and Holmqvist could be solid blueliners. 28. NASHVILLE PREDATORS Prognosis: Nashville has stripped its cupboard bare, trading away top prospects like Joni Pitkanen, Steve Ott, Brooks Orpik, Philippe Sauve and Adam Munro as well as top picks in an attempt to make the playoffs. They are in a dogfight for one of the bottom two spots in the West. If they dont get one, this would be one of the all-time colossal failures, with no hope on the horizon for help. It may be painful watching their top prospects all shine as Stars for seasons to come. 27. PHILADELPHIA FLYERS Prognosis: Not as bad as it seems, with Eric Staal, Barret Jackman and Andrew Raycroft contributing at the WCFHL level. But thats it. Acquiring players like Pavel Bure made no sense and threw off the needed rebuilding process (Bergenheim for Rycroft?). The worst team in the NHL also has no draft picks until round 5 of the next draft and nothing in the pipeline their best prospect is a goaltender, and Raycroft is their franchise netminder already. If, as it should be, their draft pick turns into the heralded Alexander Ovechkin, GM Sean Conley can never say we didnt told ya so 26. VANCOUVER CANUCKS Prognosis: A young team at the WCFHL level with some good building blocks, but the prospect tank is dry. Liv has regressed, and only Hudler saves this sad sack of talent. They do have Nashvilles first rounder to go with their own, so help could be on the way shortly. 25. EDMONTON OILERS Prognosis: Get past the first four and theres trouble. Taticek and Jessiman are both highly regarded, but will have to fill into their big frames. Anderson is a maturing goaltender and Svatos could contribute soon. The rest are has-beens and never-wases. 24. NEW YORK RANGERS Prognosis: Carter has star potential, but the rest is a rag-tag bunch of (mostly) late bloomers and sleepers. Miettinen, Aitken and Michalek could be contributing already, but at what capacity? 23. DETROIT RED WINGS Prognosis: Their pro roster is veteran-laden after GM Shon Shampains retooling, but the farm still needs help. Prusek is a star goalie waiting to happen, but with Brodeur in front of him he may wait a while. Still, the talent of Eaves and Balej is hard to ignore, and Eager could develop into an Adam Deadmarsh-type player or, at worst, a fourth line lug. 22. MIGHTY DUCKS OF ANAHEIM Prognosis: OK, I think Higgins is going to be phenomenal, so maybe theyre a little higher than they deserve to be because of that. Sharp could contribute already, and Backer is a sleeper who continues to impress. It would help if one of Bendera or the aging Damphousse would finally become a backup-caliber goalie at least. 21. NEW YORK ISLANDERS Prognosis: A bunch of young talent already on their roster (Heatley, Ruutu, Arnason, Hartnell), but what you see is what you get. Ward is a highly-touted goalie, but theres no top-end player in the bunch. They get marks here for having more depth than teams rated below. 20. NEW JERSEY DEVILS Prognosis: Okay, lots of goalies. Okay, Nash and Zherdev are graduated. Harding would have started for Team Canada at the WJCs if Fleury had not returned and I suspect he would have shown his caliber as an elite netminder. Woywitka is a top prospect on defence, and I think that Boyle, while young, could be an impact player down the road. 19. COLUMBUS BLUE JACKETS Prognosis: Three of their top five prospects are goalies. Perhaps Leclaire and/or Daigneault (or Puurula, for that matter) should be moved to fill needs elsewhere, because Fleury is the franchise. They already traded away one top goalie prospect (Jeff Deslauriers, for Felix Potvin). I dont understand moving draft picks to get guys like David Oliver and Ray Schultz. Vagner has rebounded to reclaim status as a promising blueline prospect. 18. BUFFALO SABRES Prognosis: I just like the look of their system. Evseev and Anshakov were guys who fell on draft day for no real reason. Milroy, Jarrett and Chiodo have faced accusations of poor attitudes, but the talent is definitely there. Surprising that Cutta hasnt made more of an impact, his time is running out fast to do so. 17. OTTAWA SENATORS Prognosis: Steen, Bernier and Armstrong is a solid trio of forwards who project as good second-liners. If one of them can rise above that to become a true top-line player, the Sens will be in good shape. Murrays stock has fallen while Langfelds has skyrocketed. 16. PHOENIX COYOTES Prognosis: Phoenix continues to build a nice core of prospects to go along with the likes of Jason Spezza, Mike Ribeiro and Ales Kotalik. Gleason and Popovic could be their top pairing down the road, with Zizka not far behind. Tambellini is a gifted scorer. Phoenix needs someone like Auld or Patzold to develop soon with Hasek on the way out and Johnson struggling. 15. ATLANTA THRASHERS Prognosis: The fortunes of the Thrashers prospect core rest largely on Grigorenkos continued recovery from a serious auto accident earlier this year. If he can recover his prior form, Atlanta will have one of the best young forwards in hockey to go alongside a potential franchise netminder (Deslauriers) and a solid crop of rearguards led by Seabrook. Filppulas play at the WJCs this year for Finland suggests brighter things ahead. 14. LOS ANGELES KINGS Prognosis: Fehr has been dominant in the WHL this season and could be the power forward the Kings need along their skilled youth like Michael Ryder. Unfortunately, after Fehr and Ryder there isnt much up front in the cupboard. Welch and Liles could both be front-end defencemen and Stephan has shown great promise. 13. ST. LOUIS BLUES Prognosis: Hunter is the jewel and ready for game action, as are Exelby and Wanvig. Spiller has tremendous potential, and both Crombeen and McClement could be shutdown players given the right opportunity. The Blues are an old team with a franchise goalie in Theodore, so their young players will be given plenty of opportunities in the coming seasons. 12. PITTSBURGH PENGUINS Prognosis: A team in transition, the Penguins have a nice base to build from. Emery and LeNeveu form a potent 1-2 tandem in net. Perezhogin has tremendous skill and could crack their lineup next season. Rupp should already be there. 11. CALGARY FLAMES Prognosis: Polushin and Sjostrom are two of the top goal scoring forward prospects in hockey. Redenbach leads the WHL in scoring this season and has seen his status escalate accordingly. Brent has leadership qualities and Bissonnette could be ready on the back end far before anyone expects. Sabourin could add goaltending depth if Dan Blackburns injury woes continue. Will Betts ever get a fair shot? 10. MINNESOTA WILD Prognosis: Would be rated even higher if the likes of Konstantin Koltsov and Brent Burns were still considered prospects here. Lehtonen is, in these eyes, the top young goalie in hockey (a nose ahead of Fleury) and should be ready just in time for Ed Belfour to step aside. Kastsistyns medical troubles seem a thing of the past and the Belarussian star has explosive scoring power. Knyazevs a bit of a mystery, but Bell has gone from a third-round pick to the CHL Defenceman of the Year a season ago. Theyve been smart about not trying to reach for the playoffs too soon but might make them anyway. 9. TAMPA BAY LIGHTNING Prognosis: Suter is a rock and Daley is perhaps the fastest-skating defenceman on this list. Foy and Getzlaf have developed faster than expected and they have the good Mikhnov. Lasak hasnt gotten his shot but could do well. Umberger is the wild card. Plus, they will draft in the top 5 for certain, and very likely at the top look out. 8. WASHINGTON CAPITALS Prognosis: Washington has depth at every position. Komisarek and Stuart are both punishing physical defencemen that every team would love to have. Hilbert, Klepis, Morris and Papineau is a nice quartet up front Hilbert and Papineau are ready now. Ahonen and Stana are both good goaltending futures. The real sleeper here is Swiss rearguard Ramholt, who has been a revelation for Cape Breton in the Q this year. 7. DALLAS STARS Prognosis: Thanks to Nashville for sending them Pitkanen, Ott, Sauve and Orpik, which has allowed them to not rush guys like Huml and Morrisonn. Dallas has a ton of young talent already contributing (the aforementioned four, plus Zidlicky, Nedorost, Hall and Sutherby) and theres more on the way. Richards is a playmaking wizard, Lynch and Morrisonn are frontline defencemen, Bacashihua shows great promise and McLean is mature enough to be a top-6 forward for a weaker squad. 6. MONTREAL CANADIENS Prognosis: Loaded with talent. Ouellet and Mika Noronen could be the 1-2 punch as early as next season. Malone would already be a front-liner for this team and Pilar could contribute to their blueline. Fleischmanns buzz has continued to grow. Nystroms stock has cooled somewhat but hes still got loads of talent. They already have a top rookie this year in Matthew Lombardi and Malone could be the next one. 5. TORONTO MAPLE LEAFS Prognosis: Torontos traded away some good prospects this season (Ruutu, Cammalleri, Campbell, Jokinen), which is uncharacteristic, but has many more on the way. Grebeshkov is arguably the top defensive prospect in hockey, or certainly the one closest to being an impact player with Pitkanen already in the WCFHL. Stajan, Kunitz and Boyes all have tremendous potential, with Kunitz the most developed, Boyes the most talented and Stajan the most balanced of the three. Nilsson has struggled this season but a good summer would restore his glow. Vrana and Hennessy were both rated among the top 10 WCFHL prospects in the QMJHL last week by an independent scouting service. Immonen is a true sleeper, as his play for JYP of the Finnish League has been nothing short of brilliant. Wouldnt hurt if Jamie Lundmark, Jeff Taffe and Ron Hainsey lived up to their hype. 4. FLORIDA PANTHERS Prognosis: The wheelin dealin Panthers have an excellent prospect base to make more trades with. They lack a goalie, but with Luongo they might not need another one. Talent from top to bottom in this organization, with Upshall as the crown jewel and Cammalleri the one most ready to contribute. Koltsov is oozing talent and everyone seems to want Perry, which can only be a good sign for the first-round selection. 3. SAN JOSE SHARKS Prognosis: This rating is as much for depth as it is for quality, as the Sharks have both. These players may have to wait a while, as San Jose has the best young core of talent on their roster of any team, by far. Garon and Toskala are terrific goalies but must sit behind Kolzig and Kiprusoff. Hale, Semenov and Backman could all play for most teams now, but not the Sharks (Redden, Niedermayer, Kaberle, Lidstrom, etc.). Theres no true superstar left on their prospect list, but do they need another one? Not really. Just phenomenal trading, drafting and scouting by GM Mikael Svensson for several years now. Someone should pass his résumé to Glen Sather. 2. CAROLINA HURRICANES Prognosis: What a top four Coburn-Belle-Martin-Kronwall could someday become. Martin and Kronwall could be their #2 and #3 defencemen right away, behind DeVries. Vanek has slid a little in some eyes but OSullivan has shown why his talent was top-10 if his attitude was sub-par. Kanko and Locke can score from anywhere, and Belle skates like the wind. Mensator is all they have for a goalie, but with DiPietro and Conklin they might not need one for a long time. 1. BOSTON BRUINS Prognosis: This is what rebuilding teams like Philadelphia and Columbus should aspire to. Theyre taking their lumps at the WCFHL level right now, but shouldnt be for long. Look at that list of ten names and then add Hamhuis, Eminger, Leopold, Kobasew, Weinhandl, Frolov, Horton, Tallinder and Ryan Miller. Scary. Not much else to say, theyve got more talent in their system than anyone else. Defence, scoring, well-rounded players and even two more first rounders to come this year. |